rich9 gaming In Penny Trial, the Moment May Have Mattered as Much as the Evidence

In some ways it is easy to see how the events of May 1, 2023, could be framed to support a narrative of a city lost in fear, exhausted by a sense of chaos. That afternoon, Daniel Penny left City Tech in Downtown Brooklyn, where he was studying architecture, and headed into Manhattan via the F train to the Flatiron branch of Life Timerich9 gaming, the elite gym and wellness merchant. A few stops in, at Second Avenue, an unhinged Jordan Neely got on and threw his jacket to the floor.

He started ranting about deprivation — about wanting ginger ale, about not caring if he ended up at Rikers, about feeling ready to die. Whether he mentioned wanting to kill anyone is unclear; witnesses offered differing accounts. But he seemed to be unarmed, directing his tirade at no one in particular.

Mr. Penny, a former Marine with a green belt from the corps’ martial arts program, looked at the frightened women and children around him and immediately sought to subdue a man they believed to be dangerous, grabbing him from behind and putting him in a chokehold. According to records from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, only 30 seconds passed between the time the train left Second Avenue and when it arrived at the next station.

At that point, everyone fearing this person who seemed so combustible could get off. Still, Mr. Penny held to the chokehold, exerting varying degrees of pressure, for nearly another five and a half minutes. Mr. Neely was pronounced dead at Lenox Health hospital in Greenwich Village. A medical examiner determined that he had died as a result of compression to the neck.

On Monday morning, after just a brief period of deliberation, jurors acquitted Mr. Penny on the charge of criminally negligent homicide. The judge overseeing the case had already dismissed the higher charge of manslaughter in the second degree after jurors said on Friday that they could not unanimously come to an agreement on that count. Ultimately, the verdict — rendered in a case involving a momentary eruption of erratic behavior by an unstable man — suggests the extent to which New Yorkers have lost faith in the prospect of their physical safety.

In a strikingly convivial conversation with detectives at the Fifth Precinct on the day of the confrontation, Mr. Penny would describe the man he put in his grip as a “crackhead,” claiming that “these” were the “guys” who were “pushing people in front of trains.” However glaring the bias, the assumption was one any of us might have made. All but two of the 11 witnesses who testified at the trial said that Mr. Neely’s presence amounted to the scariest experience they’d had on a subway.

We are having trouble retrieving the article content.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.rich9 gaming